Let‘s talk about evil.
Mar. 13th, 2009 08:53 pmEvil things actually. Or the evil things people do. I’m not going to talk about evil people - not really. Partly because I think genuinely evil people are rare to the point of being non-existent (oh there are plenty of BAD people, but evil?) but mainly because I think calling people evil is one of the biggest cop outs of all time.
And that’s what I’m mainly going to ramble on about - cop outs. All the little excuses we use every day to ignore evil. I don’t mean justify evil (though, gods know, we do enough justifying evil) I mean all those little lies and assumptions we tell and make so we don’t have to think about it too hard.
Let’s take one of the common ones - computer games (or whatever music genre you don’t like or books or violent horror films, take your pic). It seems that the German kid who has committed one of those sensational and tragic massacres recently was a fan of Counter Strike. Suddenly, that’s it - we have vast numbers of people who really should know better deciding this is the reason.
And they should know better, because it is ridiculously stupid. Let’s have a quick and easy research - hell, let’s just use Wiki, the lasiest research tool known to man. Now, according to Wiki Counter Strike ALONE (not including spin offs, different editions or any other game in the Shoot ‘em Up genre) sold 4.2 MILLION copies.
Now, if this game was a significant cause of people snapping and opening fire on those around them wouldn’t you expect the body count to be a mite higher by now? I mean, 4.2 million people for this game alone (so we can comfortably say, what, 8, 10 million for people exposed to games of that type?) then we’re going to have a lot of people sat alone in small rooms polishing weapons and cackling “one day, one day they’ll paaaaay!!!” Now throw in all the other media that are supposed to be a cause of such violence - just about every music form ever (hells, they were saying it about 50s rock and roll which is snooze-worthily tame. I bet back in the 18th century people were tutting angrily about that terrible Mozart music causing violent crime left right and centre) films, books - you name it. Well, if all of these were a major factor in killing sprees we’d have to employ an army of people just to move the bodies.
I don’t mean to diminish the tragedy of this or any other massacre. They are horrific, heart rending events. The fact these events are so terrible is why we need to look at them and not dismiss them. And that’s what blaming music or computer games or dress sense or whatever does. It dismisses it. Why did he go on a killing spree? He played counter-strike. Right, tut under your breath, engage in moralising, mention bibles in schools, move on to next sound bite.
It’s not the computer games. It’s not the music. It’s not the clothes. It’s not the films. It’s not because someone’s weird or insane or odd or off - or rather that’s part of the result along with the killing. It’s not because someone’s inherently evil. All these are excuses. Convenient ways to file the event away. Easy ways of saying “It won’t happen here.” Or, more tellingly, “me and mine would never do such a thing.” “Real people don’t do that kind of thing.”
Because that’s part of the scary part, isn’t it? The idea that these killers are people - not crazy, not insane, not corrupted by some evil influence. Just people. Maybe sick people. Maybe hurting people. Maybe people that our societies have pushed aside or pushed away. Maybe just people who needed help. In the end we don’t want to think that, hey, we failed this person. That it might just be our fault. That something is wrong with us and the way we do things. That maybe we could have fixed this.
It’s important to talk about evil. But not evil people - evil people can be shut away and forgotten. No, it’s important to talk about evil things and the whys and the hows because otherwise it’s going to keep on happening.
And that’s what I’m mainly going to ramble on about - cop outs. All the little excuses we use every day to ignore evil. I don’t mean justify evil (though, gods know, we do enough justifying evil) I mean all those little lies and assumptions we tell and make so we don’t have to think about it too hard.
Let’s take one of the common ones - computer games (or whatever music genre you don’t like or books or violent horror films, take your pic). It seems that the German kid who has committed one of those sensational and tragic massacres recently was a fan of Counter Strike. Suddenly, that’s it - we have vast numbers of people who really should know better deciding this is the reason.
And they should know better, because it is ridiculously stupid. Let’s have a quick and easy research - hell, let’s just use Wiki, the lasiest research tool known to man. Now, according to Wiki Counter Strike ALONE (not including spin offs, different editions or any other game in the Shoot ‘em Up genre) sold 4.2 MILLION copies.
Now, if this game was a significant cause of people snapping and opening fire on those around them wouldn’t you expect the body count to be a mite higher by now? I mean, 4.2 million people for this game alone (so we can comfortably say, what, 8, 10 million for people exposed to games of that type?) then we’re going to have a lot of people sat alone in small rooms polishing weapons and cackling “one day, one day they’ll paaaaay!!!” Now throw in all the other media that are supposed to be a cause of such violence - just about every music form ever (hells, they were saying it about 50s rock and roll which is snooze-worthily tame. I bet back in the 18th century people were tutting angrily about that terrible Mozart music causing violent crime left right and centre) films, books - you name it. Well, if all of these were a major factor in killing sprees we’d have to employ an army of people just to move the bodies.
I don’t mean to diminish the tragedy of this or any other massacre. They are horrific, heart rending events. The fact these events are so terrible is why we need to look at them and not dismiss them. And that’s what blaming music or computer games or dress sense or whatever does. It dismisses it. Why did he go on a killing spree? He played counter-strike. Right, tut under your breath, engage in moralising, mention bibles in schools, move on to next sound bite.
It’s not the computer games. It’s not the music. It’s not the clothes. It’s not the films. It’s not because someone’s weird or insane or odd or off - or rather that’s part of the result along with the killing. It’s not because someone’s inherently evil. All these are excuses. Convenient ways to file the event away. Easy ways of saying “It won’t happen here.” Or, more tellingly, “me and mine would never do such a thing.” “Real people don’t do that kind of thing.”
Because that’s part of the scary part, isn’t it? The idea that these killers are people - not crazy, not insane, not corrupted by some evil influence. Just people. Maybe sick people. Maybe hurting people. Maybe people that our societies have pushed aside or pushed away. Maybe just people who needed help. In the end we don’t want to think that, hey, we failed this person. That it might just be our fault. That something is wrong with us and the way we do things. That maybe we could have fixed this.
It’s important to talk about evil. But not evil people - evil people can be shut away and forgotten. No, it’s important to talk about evil things and the whys and the hows because otherwise it’s going to keep on happening.