Which largely caused me to roll my eyes and move on. Maybe consider for a moment why anyone would consider Elton John any kind of source for ecclesiastical or theological insight (you totes have to go to Lady Gaga for that, y’know).
Naturally, being neither Christian nor having any real place for Jesus in any part of my belief system or philosophy I am rather indifferent as to any biographical information about Jesus.
I’m also not entirely sure why anyone cares, to be honest. First of all, it’s an ultimate example of non-verifiable conjecture. Secondly, and correct me if I’m wrong since I’m no theologian, I can’t see anything in the purported messages of Jesus, teachings of Jesus or miracles of Jesus that matter whether he was gay, straight, bi, asexual, omnisexual or indeed, any kind of sexuality at all.
People have huffily said that Elton John has been grossly disrespectful to Christians and, even if I’m not a Christian, didn’t I agree that it was an unwarranted and unnecessary attack?
And I say no. I understand the original quote was “Jesus was a compassionate, super-intelligent gay man.”
Now, I don’t accept any of that as accurate – but disrespectful? Compassionate? I think most followers of Jesus wouldn’t be offended by that description. Super-intelligent? Again, not really much ground to be offended there. Man? Well, maybe some may argue that as the son of god man is not appropriate – but it does seem to be a commonplace descriptor. So we’re left with…
Gay.
So, if you expect me to agree that Elton John’s comment was disrespectful, insulting, denigrating or otherwise naughty-bad-wrong then you are expecting me to agree that calling someone “gay” is to disrespect them, insult them or denigrate them. If you want me to accept that his comment was an ATTACK then you’re asking me to accept that calling someone gay (other than in the “so gay” context and I think that can be safely set aside, all things considered) is an attack. I’m not accepting that.
As to disrespectful to Christian beliefs – it is disrespectful to the homophobic belief that being gay is wrong/bad/sinful. And I’m all for disrespecting that bigoted, hateful belief to the hilt and back. Bigotry should be disrespected. Prejudice is NOT OWED respect
So, here’s the thing the way I see it: If you’re insulted or offended by the suggestion that Jesus was gay, that’s telling me that you think gay is an insult or being gay is somehow a bad thing. Now if you want to argue accuracy then that’s different (and a matter of rather supreme indifference to me, nor do I particularly see why anyone else gives a damn). But if you are arguing insult, offence, disrespect etc then, from what I can see, that only fits in the context where BEING GAY IS WRONG.
Shockingly, this argument does not earn much in the way of sympathy from me.
Now, if you want to see an example of something that is disrespectful we have this lovely bumper sticker. See? That is how you do insulting, offensive and disrespectful.